Call Us: 1300 093 795
Email Us: enquiry@elek.com.au

  • Login Cable Pro
Menu
  • Login Cable Pro
Electrotechnik
  • Software
    • Cable Pro Web (AU)
    • Cable Pro Web (UK)
    • Protection Coordination
    • SafeGrid Earthing
    • Cable High Voltage
    • Cable Pulling
    • Bare Conductor Ratings
    • Power Bundle
  • Resources
    • Article Categories
      • Low Voltage Design
      • Earthing Design
      • High Voltage Cable Design
      • Electrical Software
      • Arc Flash Studies
    • Tutorials
    • Free Calculators
      • Cable Sizing AS3008
      • Cable Sizing BS7671
      • Voltage Drop
      • Arc Flash
      • Earth Cable Sizing
      • Fault Loop Impedance
      • Earth Grid Resistance
      • Earth Grid Conductor Sizing
      • Earthing Rods Resistance
      • Lightning Protection Design
      • Relay Tripping Time
      • Equivalent Thermal Resistance
    • Courses
      • SafeGrid Earthing Software Course
    • Technical Publications
    • Training and Certification
  • Support
    • Support Overview
    • Help Portal
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Careers
    • Reseller & Partner Program
  • Login
    • Cable Pro Web Login
    • Training Courses Login
    • Customer Licence Portal
  • TRY FOR FREE
  • SCHEDULE A DEMO
  • TRY FOR FREE
  • SCHEDULE A DEMO
  • TRY FOR FREE
Menu
  • Software
    • Cable Pro Web (AU)
    • Cable Pro Web (UK)
    • Protection Coordination
    • SafeGrid Earthing
    • Cable High Voltage
    • Cable Pulling
    • Bare Conductor Ratings
    • Power Bundle
  • Resources
    • Article Categories
      • Low Voltage Design
      • Earthing Design
      • High Voltage Cable Design
      • Electrical Software
      • Arc Flash Studies
    • Tutorials
    • Free Calculators
      • Cable Sizing AS3008
      • Cable Sizing BS7671
      • Voltage Drop
      • Arc Flash
      • Earth Cable Sizing
      • Fault Loop Impedance
      • Earth Grid Resistance
      • Earth Grid Conductor Sizing
      • Earthing Rods Resistance
      • Lightning Protection Design
      • Relay Tripping Time
      • Equivalent Thermal Resistance
    • Courses
      • SafeGrid Earthing Software Course
    • Technical Publications
    • Training and Certification
  • Support
    • Support Overview
    • Help Portal
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Careers
    • Reseller & Partner Program
  • Login
    • Cable Pro Web Login
    • Training Courses Login
    • Customer Licence Portal
  • TRY FOR FREE
  • SCHEDULE A DEMO
  • TRY FOR FREE
  • SCHEDULE A DEMO
  • TRY FOR FREE

Home / Articles / Earthing Design

Modelling earthing rods surrounded with bentonite

Table of Contents

Using bentonite to reduce resistance

Sometimes it is not possible to achieve the desired reduction in ground resistance by adding more grid conductors or ground rods. An alternate solution is to effectively increase the diameter of the electrode by modifying the soil surrounding.  It has been shown that the inner shell of soil closest to the electrode has the greatest affect on the resistance as measured to remote earth [1].  This phenomenon can be taken advantage of by surrounding the electrode or rod with a material like bentonite, a natural clay containing the mineral montmorillonite, to lower the resistance.

According to the results of reference [2], rods that are surrounded with bentonite show a significant lowering of resistance to remote ground as compared with direct driven rods.  The reduction in resistance is a direct result of increasing the effective surface area of the ground rod.  As you increase the surface area in contact with a given resistivity soil, the resistance of the rod to remote ground will drop according to the relationship:

bentonite formula 1 - Modelling earthing rods surrounded with bentonite
bentonite formula 2 - Modelling earthing rods surrounded with bentonite

How to model rods surrounded with bentonite

Bentonite clay has a very low, almost negligible resistivity, so by surrounding the rod, for example, within a 152mm (6 in.) cylinder of bentonite, we have effectively installed a 152mm (6 in.) ground rod and we can expect the resistance of the rod to drop.

A test grid with a 20 m long rod is investigated to find out how to model the rod surrounded by bentonite.  To represent a rod surrounded with bentonite in software we include several vertical conductors of which the circumscribed circle has the area of the bentonite.

Figure 1 shows that the rod surrounded with bentonite is modelled as four and twelve normal size vertical conductors respectively.

(a) Modelled as 4 vertical conductors
(a) Modelled as 4 vertical conductors
(b) Modelled as12 vertical conductors
(b) Modelled as12 vertical conductors

Figure 1 – Two models of a rod surrounded by bentonite

 

The grid conductor area is assumed as 70 mm2 and the cross-section area of the bentonite is assumed as 10000 mm2. Table 1 shows the grid impedance of different cases.

Table 1 – Grid impedance of different cases

No. Cases Grid impedance (Ω) Variation compared with 1st case
1 A 10000 mm2 rod 4.213 N/A
2 A 70 mm2 rod 5.809 + 37.88%
3 Four 70 mm2 vertical conductors used to model rod surrounded by bentonite 4.365 + 3.61%
4 Twelve 70 mm2 vertical conductors used to model rod surrounded by bentonite 4.290 + 1.83%

The rod surrounded by bentonite can significantly reduce the grid impedance according to case 1 and 2. In SafeGrid, several small cross-section area rods cane be used to model the rod with bentonite. The results of case 3 and 4 validate the effectiveness of this method. Their grid impedances are close to that of a 10000 mm2 rod. Based on the comparison between 3rd and 4th cases, the grid impedance becomes less and closer to the ideal situation as the number of vertical conductors increases.

Conclusion

The use of moist bentonite clay can improve the performance of earthing rods effectively by reducing their effective resistance. Grid impedance and grid potential rise (GPR) will thereby decrease significantly.

In SafeGrid Earthing Software, vertical conductors located at the vertices of an equilateral polygon which has the same area of bentonite can be applied to model the rod surrounded by bentonite.  As the number of these conductors increases, the calculated resistance results for the rod approach that for an actual rod surrounded with bentonite.

References

[1]        “IEEE Guide for Safety in AC Substation Grounding,” IEEE Std 80-2013 (Revision of IEEE Std 80-2000/ Incorporates IEEE Std 80-2013/Cor 1-2015), pp. 1-226, 2015, doi: 10.1109/IEEESTD.2015.7109078.

[2]        W. R. Jones, “Bentonite Rods Assure Ground Rod Installation In Problem Soils,” IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, vol. PAS-99, no. 4, pp. 1343-1346, 1980, doi: 10.1109/TPAS.1980.319556.

SafeGrid Earthing Software

Easily design safe earthing systems in compliance with Standards.

Try For Free

Print this article:

Share on print
Print

SafeGrid Earthing Software

SafeGrid Earthing Software

Easily design safe earthing systems in compliance with Standards.

Try For Free

As used by:

For information or to speak with our helpful advisors

GET IN TOUCH

GET IN TOUCH

Electrotechnik-Footer

Electrical Power Systems Design & Analysis Software

FOLLOW US

social-fb
social-yt
social-li

SOFTWARE

  • Cable Pro Web
  • Protection Coordination
  • SafeGrid Earthing
  • Cable High Voltage
  • Cable Pulling
  • Line Rate
  • Power Bundle
Menu
  • Cable Pro Web
  • Protection Coordination
  • SafeGrid Earthing
  • Cable High Voltage
  • Cable Pulling
  • Line Rate
  • Power Bundle

RESOURCES & SUPPORT

  • Software Tutorials
  • Technical Publications
  • Training and Certification
  • Customer Licence Portal
Menu
  • Software Tutorials
  • Technical Publications
  • Training and Certification
  • Customer Licence Portal

CONTACT US

Email:
enquiry@elek.com.au

Need Help?
Lodge a Support Ticket

Phone:
1300 093 795
International:
+61 (0)2 8231 6673

FREE TECHNICAL NEWS

© 2022 All Rights Reserved    Privacy Policy Quality Policy Terms of Use

Schedule a Demo for Cable High Voltage

Look No Further. Get Started Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Schedule a Demo for SafeGrid Earthing

Look No Further. Get Started Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
SafeGrid Earthing Free Trial
  • Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you'll be able to download the software.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Cable High Voltage Free Trial
  • Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you'll be able to download the software.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
SafeGrid Earthing 14 day Free Trial

Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you’ll be able to download the software.

  • Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you'll be able to download the software.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CLOSE

Cable High Voltage 14 day Free Trial

Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you’ll be able to download the software.

  • Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you'll be able to download the software.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CLOSE

  • We strive for 100% customer satisfaction. If we fell short, please tell us more so we can address your concerns.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

If you do not wish to address your concerns here and prefer to post a review, click here.

Cable Pro (PC) Free Trial

Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you’ll be able to download the software.

  • Fill out your details below to begin your trial. Once your information has been submitted you'll be able to download the software.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

CLOSE